The Federal Supreme Court concluded a relevant judgment on the civil liability regime of internet application providers for content published by third parties. In RE No. 1,037,396 ED, the Court recognized the partial and progressive unconstitutionality of article 19 of the Internet Civil Framework, establishing a new interpretation for the provision until specific legislation on the matter is enacted.
In the original wording, article 19 conditioned, as a rule, the civil liability of the provider to non-compliance with a specific judicial order for removal. In other words, the platform could only be held liable if, after judicial determination, it failed to make unavailable the content identified as illicit. For the STF, this model, although preserving important values such as freedom of expression and legal certainty, proved insufficient in certain situations for the protection of fundamental rights and democracy itself.
The decision does not entirely eliminate article 19. What was established was a more complex and segmented regime, with different consequences according to the nature of the content, the type of service provided, the degree of illegality involved, and the conduct adopted by the provider. In some cases, the requirement for a judicial order remains; in others, joint liability, relative presumption of fault, or reinforced duties of care and prevention come into existence.
Among the central points of the decision, the joint liability of providers stands out in cases involving third-party content that constitutes a crime or illicit act, except when there is reasonable doubt about the illegality, after diligent and qualified analysis. The relative presumption of fault was also recognized in situations involving paid advertisements, boosting, and artificial mechanisms for inorganic dissemination of illicit content.
The STF also established specific duties of care regarding content related to serious crimes, such as anti-democratic acts, terrorism, crimes against children and adolescents, human trafficking, incitement to discrimination and gender violence. In these cases, liability is especially associated with the platform's systemic failure to prevent or remove illicit content from mass circulation.
On the other hand, certain services remain subject to the original regime of article 19, due to constitutional protection of communication secrecy. This is the case for emails, private messaging, closed video or voice meetings, and other services that do not interfere with the communicative and informational flow. In crimes against honor, the requirement for a specific judicial order also remains, as a rule, although removal through extrajudicial notification is admitted.
Another relevant point concerns marketplaces. For these agents, the STF indicated the application of the Consumer Defense Code, recognizing the existence of an underlying consumer relationship and ruling out the automatic application of the same regime attributed to other digital platforms.
The decision also imposes structural obligations on platforms, including duties of transparency, creation of service channels, notification systems, due process, periodic reports, and legal representation in Brazil. With this, the performance of platforms is evaluated not only reactively, in the face of a judicial order or specific notification, but also based on their organizational capacity to prevent, identify, and respond to risks in the digital environment.
It is important to highlight that the STF did not institute strict liability. The liability of providers continues to depend on the configuration of fault, failure, or non-compliance with specific duties, according to each case. The central change is in raising the standard of diligence required from platforms regarding illicit content, especially when involving scale, recurrence, monetization, boosting, or relevant risk to fundamental rights.
Sudbrack Madalena prepared a Client Alert with the systematization of the theses established by the STF, presenting in a didactic manner the main liability regimes applicable, the exceptions, the structural duties, and the practical impacts of the decision for companies, digital platforms, legal departments, compliance officers, and professionals working with technology, regulation, and civil liability.
The material has an informative purpose and seeks to contribute to understanding the recent transformations in the legal regime of digital platforms in Brazil.
Access the complete Client Alert and check the analysis of the theses established by the STF.
Merely informative material. Does not substitute specific legal analysis for concrete cases.
